World Socialist Radio – Corbyn’s Crumbs of Comfort

 


Corybn’s Crumbs of Comfort. Lord Desai’s Retort. Cooking The Books September 2025.
byThe Socialist Party of Great Britain

Creating an egalitarian society through a redistribution of wealth within capitalism is a pipe-dream as it goes against the logic of the system. Capitalism is based on a minority owning the means of wealth production and on these being used to generate profits that are accumulated as more wealth for the owners. Inequality of wealth ownership and the tendency for the wealthy to get wealthier are built into the system.

Attempting to counter this will mean that the new party will end up being a mere party of protest, spending its time criticising the government for not doing what it ‘demands’ and ‘resisting’ when the workings of the capitalist economy force the government to make things worse.

The Times’s obituary (4 August) of the economist Lord Desai who died at the end of July recounted the following anecdote:

‘“Marx wasn’t against home ownership. In fact he owned his own house,” Desai insisted when challenged about his own two properties. What Marx was against, he added, was using property to exploit workers. “Marx had no objection to the ownership of consumer durables”.’

Taken from the September 2025 edition of The Socialist Standard.

World Socialist Radio is the official podcast of The Socialist Party of Great Britain. We have one single aim: the establishment of a society in which all productive resources – land, water, factories, transport, etc. – are taken into common ownership, and in which the sole motive for production is the fulfilment of human needs and wants.

https://www.worldsocialism.org/spgb/world-socialist-radio/


States of Terror

The continuing horror in and around Gaza defies reason. An initial terror countered by a greater, protracted one. Eventually there’ll be an end, but what will the death tally be, hostages and civilians? It will by then be the peace of the graveyard. Life being eked out amongst the ruins by those who survive.

Political leaders of states looking on have belatedly decided to act, by reviving the two states solution. This involves recognition of the state of Palestine, to the chagrin of Israel’s government.

Surely the fundamental problem is the existence of nation states, each ruthlessly pursuing its own interests, ultimately at the expense of others. In a world driven, and riven, by competition, it is difficult to see how the formal recognition of another state profoundly changes anything.

Existence for two states, Russia and Ukraine, patently has not ensured peace between them. Israel and Palestine may develop accords, but just as likely become embroiled in further conflicts of competing interests, presuming recognition ends the present bellicosity.

Palestine action

Is resetting battle lines

No state solution

D. A.

Hypocrisy

If truth is the first casualty of war, hypocrisy is its staunch ally.

On Thursday, 17th September, a United Nations Security Council resolution calling for an immediate, unconditional and permanent ceasefire in the Gaza Strip, and the release of all hostages by Hamas, was voted on by the 15 members.

Although fourteen were in favour, it was vetoed by the 15th, the USA. As one of the five permanent members, America has this longstanding, if democratically dubious, privilege. This is the same state that frequently condemns Russia for its targeting civilians, by military action, in Ukraine.

One of the other five members of that elite group, Russia, must have voted in favour of the resolution. The very same Russia undertaking ballistic aggression against its own neighbour even as it was casting that vote.

The presidents of both countries can undoubtedly concoct self-justifying excuses for the inexcusable. If civilians are being subjected to terror attacks, it surely means those prosecuting those attacks, or facilitating them, are, by definition terrorists.

However, it is also hypocritical to single out these states and their leaders while, at the same time, continuing to lend even tacit support to the notion of the nation. Russia and America are not unique in their belligerent involvements.

Competition is in the nature of capitalism, so it cannot be surprising that capitalist nation states are constantly seeking advantage at the expense of each other. Warfare is the inevitable merciless expression of this competition.

It will continue to be so for as long as nation states and capitalism are allowed to exist. No matter what UN votes are held, successfully or frustrated. The only antidote to war and long term solutions for Gaza, Ukraine et al, is socialism.

Voting for peace means

Treating pain, not the disease

Veto capitals

D. A.   

Badly treated


recent report has shown that people with learning disabilities and autism are dying on average nearly twenty years younger than the rest of the population. And almost two in five of their deaths are avoidable, caused most commonly by influenza, pneumonia and heart disease. Many people with learning disabilities or autism experience delay in care, or their treatment guidelines are not met.

‘People with a learning disability and their families deserve better,’ said the chief executive of Mencap. ‘In this day and age, no one should die early because they don’t get the right treatment.’

This is a particularly unacceptable example of the shortcomings of health care under capitalism.



https://www.worldsocialism.org/spgb/

Socialist Sonnet No. 203

Uniting the Kingdom, by George

 

Fearful laidly wyrm, gruesome millipede

Of grotesque proportions. Its poisonous

Venom paralyses reason in case

Some humane diversion just might succeed

In making it pause for thought and realise

Its determined course, the slippery slope

It’s slithering down, is one without hope,

A pathway of misdirection and lies.

Leaders look down from swish crystal towers,

Concealing their contempt for this creature,

Certain tomorrow’s headlines will feature

Their agendas, strengthening their powers.

Meanwhile the rough beast, having been reborn,

Slouches towards Paris, Berlin and London.

 

D. A.

World Socialist Radio -How Labour Changed

 



Labour didn’t fundamentally reform capitalism. Instead, capitalism reshaped Labour, gradually pulling it away from egalitarian ideals toward embracing profit-driven policies and business-friendly governance.

Originally formed in 1906 as a trade union pressure group in parliament, in 1918 the Labour Party adopted as its long-term aim a nationalised economy. This, together with a redistribution of wealth to create a less unequal society, was to be achieved gradually by measures taken by a succession of Labour governments.

This strategy — Labourism — failed, and how! Instead of Labour gradually changing capitalism, it was capitalism that gradually changed Labour. Learning from the experience of being in government, that the only way capitalism can run is as an economic system driven by profit-making and that this has to be given priority, Labour gradually evolved from an alleged labour party into an avowed capitalist party..



https://www.worldsocialism.org/spgb/world-socialist-radio/


Common Denominator

What do meat, drugs and refugees have in common?

All three are subject to being smuggled into Britain (and elsewhere no doubt). The Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee (EFRA) recently reported the quantity of illicit meat discovered on its way through Dover had risen from 13 tonnes between January and April 2023 to 70 tonnes for the same period in 2025.

The twin concern is that foot and mouth disease could easily be imported this way, and lack of quality control threatens public health via human consumption.

Both drugs and (especially at the moment) refugees being smuggled is a frequent media item.

The real common denominator is, of course, profit. Smuggling is an entrepreneurial activity, economically motivated. Illegality is merely an obstacle to be circumvented. It is a capitalist enterprise centred on financial return on dealing in commodities.

People are readily reduced to being commodities by dint of becoming refugees seeking non-legal routes to asylum.

National borders serve to provide a context for exploitation.

By sea or by air

Lines drawn on maps prove nothing

Crossed by bottom lines

 D. A.

Profit Before People

 

 


(Remembering Gawber)

 

March 2025 saw the fortieth anniversary of the end of the Miner’s Strike. Six months on, this day marks another coal mining anniversary, the ninetieth of the North Gawber Colliery Explosion. The Lidgett Seam was known to be gassy, the ventilation often inadequate.

On the afternoon of the 12th September 1935, Mapplewell, Barnsley, became the tragic scene of an underground detonation. It resulted 19 deaths and a further 5 injuries.

It is an example of the cost in working class lives of capitalism’s relentless pursuit of profit, subordinating meeting need. In cases such as this the need for safe working conditions.

While the deep mining of coal has now gone from Britain, it remains a dangerous occupation, along with other types of mining, in many parts of the world. Workers are still being killed in the pursuit of profit.

Once headlines at home

Mining’s continuing cost

Remains in the dark

D.A.