Author: cynical but optimistic

Great Memories

A week is a long time in politics it was once said. A week ago a fun time was being had by many at the Socialist Party’s Summer School. The theme was populism.

There was lots of time in between the interesting and educational talks to catch up with old comrades and to meet new ones.

Oscar Wilde said he could resist everything but temptation. The temptation to purchase books and other things proved too great for many of us.

A games activity started out as competitive between several teams but in the spirit of true socialism ended up in a collective effort to solve the Bletchley Park level quiz.

One of the highlights of the weekend, among many, was the interesting display of t-shirts worn, by the males, on a Marxian theme.

The t-shirt pictured has the message in  Catalan that in life choices have to be made, fence sitting is not an option, sides have to be chosen. The wearer, like the rest of us, chose socialism.

We look forward to repeating the positive experience again next year.

Himalayan flash floods

With record summer heatwaves and ‘weather whiplash’ events, global warming is fast becoming normalised. Now shocking video has emerged of unsurvivable flash floods in Nepal and Tibet, probably caused by a melting Himalayan glacier. Geologists have been warning about this for years, and there have been similar previous floods.

The death toll continues to rise as the water recedes. Rescue work is underway as local villagers scramble to help survivors, and aid workers pour in from elsewhere. But in the boardrooms of the world’s corporate powerhouses, eyes do not move from the bottom line figures. Nothing matters except profit, even while capitalism heats the planet and melts glaciers.

Until we abolish this inhumane system, these human tragedies will continue.

worldsocialism.org/spgb/

Poverty in families

A recent study showed that nearly half of parents are struggling financially after having a baby.

In some cases this has even led to them watering down baby formula milk in order to save money. This can be really serious for an infant, as it may result in growth problems and developmental delays. Baby banks supply clothes, nappies and baby wipes to parents, but get few donations of baby milk.

This is what life can be like for some of the poorest workers under capitalism: essential items such as baby formula can barely be afforded. A society that results in this level of poverty needs to be replaced by one where meeting human need is the priority.

worldsocialism.org/spgb/

Mass delusion?

SPGB Summer School on Zoom

Talks will be streamed through the SPGB’s Zoom channel. To connect to a Zoom meeting, click https://zoom.us/j/7421974305

 

Friday 21 August
7.15pm—8.45pm
Populism As A Keyword

Words change meaning, and have contested meanings (especially political words). This talk will look at the origin of the word ‘Populism’, showing how it has roots in particular movements, moments and practices that defined it at birth and have shaped its evolution into the word we use now. The talk will range from the Wizard of Oz to the Beatles, and will then come back to try and understand what populism means today.

Speaker: Bill Martin

Saturday 22 August
10:00am—11:30am
Rage Against The Dying Of The Right

The rise of populism and fascistic politics is undeniable. But should world socialists be too pessimistic? Beneath the waves of fascistic performative politics tectonic changes in class consciousness appear to be happening. This talk will try to look at populism as an insight to what really matters: the state of global working class consciousness.

  • Are we being ‘gaslit’ about the strength of populism?
  • Is this really a new era? Or the same old authoritarianism of capitalism, just without the pretence?
  • To what extent is the working class around the world genuinely embracing conservative or nationalistic views?
  • Is the rise of the far-right actually a desperate tactic by a ruling class running out of ideas?
  • Is this just a temporary tech-driven anomaly (subsidized by billionaires and driven by outraged algorithms) which humanity will soon learn to overcome?

Speaker: Brian Gardner

2.00pm—3.30pm
In Search Of Left-Wing Populism

Most populist parties are right-wing (Reform UK, Fidesz in Hungary), but it has been suggested that populism could also apply to left-wing organisations (such as the Greens, maybe, or Podemos in Spain). An article in Jacobin suggested that left populists ‘have prioritized a defense of popular over national sovereignty’; this would be in contrast to national populism, an ideology which prioritizes ‘the culture and interests of the nation’ (Eatwell & Goodwin).

We will explore claims such as these and look at how standard populist positions could apply to the left, such as the division between the people and the elite, and opposition to pluralism. Is populism really such a vague notion that it can include a wide range of views?

Speaker: Paul Bennett

7.15pm—8.45pm
Red-Brown Politics In Russia And Beyond

Post-Soviet Russia has witnessed the emergence of a distinctive ‘red-brown’ political ideology, blending Soviet and Stalinist themes with ideas from the nationalist or neo-Tsarist far right. As early as 1996, the leader of the official Communist Party of the Russian Federation was speaking of Russia’s innate imperial destiny and endorsing the old Tsarist slogan ‘Orthodoxy, autocracy, popularity’ (the last word here could also be translated ‘nationality’, or indeed ‘populism’).

The left / right synthesis began in the Russian opposition, among figures like the ‘National Bolshevik’ novelist Eduard Limonov, the ‘patriotic’ general Albert Makashov, and perhaps above all the writer and newspaper editor Aleksandr Prokhanov. But aspects of it have subsequently been borrowed by the Kremlin’s propaganda operations, for audiences both inside Russia and abroad. And attempts to do something similar have been made in other countries (even, to a limited extent, in Britain): ‘populists’ of left and right have been invited to sink their differences and join forces against the ‘globalist elite’. This talk will provide an introduction to the ‘red-brown’ worldview: was Stalin a saint? Will he yet come back from the dead to redeem his people? And could any of it catch on here?

Guest speaker Edmund Griffiths

Edmund Griffiths is the author of Aleksandr Prokhanov and Post-Soviet Esotericism (2023): “a veritable map of ideological trends and fads in a disoriented […] society” (Slavic Review)

Sunday 23 August
10.00am—11.30am
Should / Could Socialism Be Populist?

Populism is any political message that’s popular, regardless of merit or political orientation. Ideas become popular when they resonate with how people think. And just how do they think? In Thinking, Fast and Slow (2011), psychologist and Nobel prize-winning behavioural economist Daniel Kahneman identifies two modes of thought. System 1 is fast, heuristic and emotional. System 2 is slow, effortful, logical and dispassionate.

In the whirl of everyday life, says Kahneman, people get by with System 1 thinking. But that’s highly vulnerable to manipulation by populist politicians. We generally explain the socialist case in the language of System 2 thinking, because we need people to understand it, not just react emotionally to it.

Which gives us a problem. If socialism is ever to succeed, it must first become popular, and to do that, it must contend with System 1 thinking. People won’t listen to us if we don’t speak their language. Is a populist socialist approach possible? What would it even look like?

Speaker: Paddy Shannon

Summer of discontent

 

Grimly facing drought, hosepipe bans, wildfires and yet another heatwave? You won’t be comforted to know that ‘greenhouse gas concentrations, global sea level and ocean heat content all reached record highs in 2025’ (phys.org). European rivers are at record lows. The US has had its hottest July on record, as has the Sahel, Central America, France and Spain. And don’t stock up your freezer with ice cream because you could soon be facing rolling energy blackouts.

It’s not all bad news though. Water company bosses are still getting bonuses, oil companies are cashing in like never before, and tech stocks are going stratospheric.

Still think capitalism is humanity’s best hope? We say it’s time to consider the alternative.

worldsocialism.org/spgb/

Nagasaki mon amour

Some events, like some people, are inextricably linked together. Hiroshima and Nagasaki are one such event.

Two events in reality, following the dropping of an atom bomb on Hiroshima a few days later, 9th August 1945, another atom bomb was used to kill occupants of the city of Nagasaki.

Extract from Socialist Standard November 2019

The atom bombs dropped by the United States on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in 1945 – affectionately named: ‘Little Boy’ and ‘Fat Man’ by the perpetrators – instantly killed 100,000 Japanese people. An additional 100,000 died of injuries and radiation poisoning in the following months. But these bombs are akin to peashooters compared to the much more powerful hydrogen bomb, invented in the 1950s, which packs a punch hundreds of times greater than its smaller cousin.

Alex Wellerstein’s Nukemap model (nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/ ) illustrates this bigger punch, by allowing the user to choose the location and size of the hydrogen bomb in a simulated detonation. I chose London as my target and selected the biggest bomb from the drop down menu; known as the ‘Tsar Bomba;’ produced in Soviet Union times, it weighs in at a whopping 100 Megatons (100,000 Kilotons) which makes it around 7000 times the size of the US atom bomb dropped on Hiroshima. Or, put another way, this single bomb exceeds the total explosive capacity of all munitions used during WWII by a factor of twenty. The result of the simulation indicated that 18 million people would be caught in the blast covering a radius stretching north to Cambridge and south to Brighton; of which around 6 million would be killed instantly and a further 6 million would suffer substantial injuries. The model helpfully clarifies that such casualties do not include the effects of radiation which are apparently too difficult to estimate. In such circumstances advising children to shelter under their school desks is not really going to cut the mustard as a strategy for survival.’

Tim Hart

https://socialiststandardmyspace.blogspot.com/2019/11/nuclear-threat-resetting-doomsday-clock.html

Why they dropped the bombs

A two part article from the Socialist Standard.

https://socialiststandardmyspace.blogspot.com/2020/09/why-they-dropped-bombs-2005.html

https://socialiststandardmyspace.blogspot.com/2020/09/blog-post_29.html

Something for the weekend: Great Train Robbery

On the 8th August 1963 train robbery occurred, the amount stolen was the equivalent of almost forty nine million pounds today. (Bank of England inflation calculator).

Mail Train robbery

The two-and-a-half million pound mail train robbery was audacious and glamorous enough to have come from the pen of the most imaginative crime fiction writer.

In that, it was typical of a recent strengthening trend in crime. The big, well planned robbery is becoming increasingly profitable for the crooks and so more and more of a headache for the police.

This is hardly surprising. The existence of private property elevates money into the key to a secure life. The moneyed man is always the privileged man and he does his best to make sure that he keeps both the money and the privileges.

There are plenty of such privileged— and honoured—men whose wealth has been amassed from the exploitation of the other class in society. Or perhaps they inherited it from their ancestors’ historical equivalent of the Cheddington hold-up.

This sort of wealth is respectable—it has come from what has been well called legal robbery, which conforms to capitalism’s needs and so its moralities.

Robbery, forgery, embezzlement, and so on, do not conform and the men who try to get rich by practising them are anything but honoured.

Be that as it may, crime is inevitable as long as capitalism lasts; offences against property make up die overwhelming majority of crimes today. Capitalism without crime, in fact, is simply impossible.

Ironically, it is capitalism itself which asks for some of its crime. Do not the armed forces, so essential to capitalism, encourage just the sort of knowledge and the mental attitudes which are useful in a desperate, quick-fire robbery?

The driver of the Cheddington train said that one of the gang advised him to keep quiet because there were some “right bastards” there. Well, it is the “right bastard” who makes an excellent Commando or bomber pilot.

All of this is not to justify nor to condone the criminal. Indeed, any one who tried to take away from the Cheddington gang any of the money they have stolen would soon find that, in their own unmistakeable way, they are as firm in their support of property rights as any bank boardroom.

Capitalism is an unpleasant social system and crime is only one of its many excrescences.’

https://socialiststandardmyspace.blogspot.com/search/label/Great%20Train%20Robbery

How near to soft rains?

Only one state has used nuclear weapons on another. On the 6th August and 9th August 1945 the USA dropped atomic bombs on the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

As of January 2026, the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists  Doomsday Clock was set at  85 seconds to midnight, four seconds closer than the 2025 setting.

In 1950 the writer Ray Bradbury had a short science fiction story published in a magazine.

The story was There will come soft rains. The story includes an image directly taken from Hiroshima of an image on a wall.

The story is set in California in August 2026. An AI controlled house that runs for the benefit of the two parents and two children living there continues to carry out its daily chores despite the outside charred wall showing their images imprinted on it by an atomic weapon flash.

We learn that this is the only house still standing here, the rest have been destroyed by nuclear weapons.

In the story, the AI management reads the father’s favourite poem. This is There will come soft rains by Sara Teasdale. Ms Teasdale wrote this in 1918. The poem is anti-war and notes that should humans wipe themselves from the face of the planet, nature won’t care one jot and will carry on quite well without humankind presence.

This, the sole remaining house is destroyed by fire.

The story ends, “Dawn showed faintly in the east. Among the ruins, one wall stood alone. Within the wall, a last voice said, over and over again and again, even as the sun rose to shine upon the heaped rubble and steam:”Today is August 5, 2026, today is August 5, 2026, today is…”

Make capitalism history before capitalism makes the human race history on Planet Earth.

NO WAR BUT CLASS WAR

Not for sale?

Infantino’s “shabby, opaque, backroom deal” apparently prepared in secret with private capital is ditched after UEFA and others statement that “demonstrated to FIFA’s President that football is not for sale”.

Hang on!! Football was sold long ago and is increasingly organised to suit pay-to-view media. This explains why fans of EPL and EFL teams now ‘benefit’ from league matches on any day from Friday to Tuesday at kick-off times to suit the TV schedules (and bugger the away fans!). This is also why the mis-named Champions League has so much group-stage dross (similarly for the Copa Libertadores) to plug so many mid-week gaps.

Sadly, the sport I love is now just an interlude between ads for bookies.