Profits Come Before Planet

 



Rainforest Action Network published a report exposing how major U.S. banks are financing hundreds of billions of dollars worth of fossil fuel projects—even as they promote their purported commitment to a low-carbon future.

“The world’s climate and energy scientists have set forth a clear mandate: In order to maintain a livable planet and prevent the global average temperature from increasing more than 1.5°C, we must rapidly and dramatically decrease greenhouse gas emissions,” the RAN report—entitled Wall Street’s Dirtiest Secret: How Fossil Fuel Expansion Depends on Big Bank Finance—states. “To meet this goal, the vast majority of oil, gas, and coal must stay in the ground,” the publication continues. “We must phase out production of some oil and gas reserves before they are fully exploited. We must stop building new infrastructure that relies on fossil fuels.”

The top six U.S. banks financed $445 billion to the top 100 companies expanding in oil, gas, and coal globally since the Paris climate agreement,” and that financing from the institutions—JPMorgan Chase, Bank of America, Citi, Wells Fargo, Morgan Stanley, and Goldman Sachs—”accounts for a whopping 33% of the funding provided” 

Virtually every single one of the world’s top banks by assets continues to fund fossil fuel expansion. Many banks justify business-as-usual financing to their fossil fuel clients by assuring the public that they are working with their clients to transition away from fossil fuels. But global banks’ top fossil fuel clients amount to a rogues’ gallery of bad actors. The clients—including Exxon, Saudi Aramco, BP, Shell, and TotalEnergies—not only are not transitioning away from fossil fuels, these companies are some of the world’s biggest expanders.

Paddy McCully, senior analyst at Paris-based Reclaim Finance, said in a statement that “U.S. banks lack policies even to stop finance to the companies expanding coal mines and power…”

RAN research manager April Merleaux said in a statement, “Companies aiming for a sustainable future must reconcile their aspirations with their profit motives.”

US Mega-Banks Behind 1/3 of Climate-Destroying Oil and Gas Expansion: Report (commondreams.org)

Grenfell – Are they really sorry?

 Richard Millett KC, lead counsel for the inquiry, said the risks that led to the June 2017 fire in west London were “well known” by many of the organisations and “ought to have been known” by all of them.

“Each and every one of the deaths that occurred in Grenfell Tower, on the 14 June 2017 was avoidable.”

He described “incompetence”, “cynical” and “possibly dishonest practices” in the building industry, “weak” building controls, failure of London Fire Brigade to learn lessons from previous fires, and a failure of government.

Since the first day of the first phase of the inquiry, Mr Millett KC has criticised the building industry companies for blaming each other in “indulging in a merry-go-round of blame”.

Referring to the companies’ closing statements this week, he said: “On day 312 of this inquiry, the merry-go-round still turns. The notes of its melody, clearly audible.”

“A tragedy of these dimensions ought to have provoked a strong sense of public responsibility,” Mr Millett KC continued.

Instead, many “core participants appear simply to have used the inquiry as an opportunity to position themselves”, so as “to minimise their own exposure to legal liability”, he said.

“A public inquiry is not the place for cleverness. But for candour.”



“If everything that has been said is correct, then nobody was to blame for the Grenfell Tower fire,” he said. “Can that really be right? Is the answer that you want to give to the survivors, to the grieving families, and to the wider public to be that the Grenfell Tower fire was just a terrible accident? Just one of those unfortunate incidents that happened occasionally?”



Blaming others



Arconic Architectural Products: The inquiry has heard the cladding manufacturer marketed the cladding knowing it would be used on tall buildings, despite having test evidence that it might be unsafe for this purpose. Arconic, however, argues that it is the job of architects and construction firms to ensure the materials they use are suitableRydon: The panel heard the building and design contractor for the tower’s refurbishment in 2015 knew, or should have known, the cladding was flammable. Rydon says it was never warned about the risk of the cladding by its manufacturer and relied on other expertsThe Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea (RBKC) and its tenant management organisation: The local council and the body managing its social housing have been accused during the inquiry of trying to cut costs by using a cheaper, non-fire retardant type of cladding. The council has admitted its building inspectors signed-off on the decisionHarley Facades: The contractor that bought and fitted the flammable cladding chosen by Rydon and the council has defended itself at the inquiry, saying it did not know the cladding had previously failed fire safety tests. However, Arconic argued the cladding came with a certificate that said it was combustible and that the cladding panels had been misused as they were not suitable for the towerCelotex and Kingspan: During the inquiry the two insulation companies have been accused of ignoring safety risks when selling products for residential tower blocks. They insist their products could be used safely with the right designsExova: The inquiry has heard that the fire safety consultants had advised the refurbishment would have no adverse effect on safety in a report during its early planning stages. However, in his closing statement earlier, Sean Brannigan KC, for the firm, said his client had “literally nothing to do” with the use of cladding containing a flammable plastic layer, a decision which was taken later in the project

Grenfell Tower Inquiry: Firms still passing the buck, barrister says – BBC News



Expanding Oil and Gas

 



Oil and gas companies are planning a “frightening” expansion that would result in 115bn tonnes of climate-heating CO2 being pumped out, equivalent to more than 24 years of US emissions, a new  analysis, by German NGO Urgewald has found.

Virtually all oil and gas companies are planning further exploitation of fossil fuels, the report found, pouring $160bn dollars into exploration since 2020. None of this investment is compatible with the International Energy Agency’s (IEA) route to reaching net zero emissions by 2050 and limiting the climate crisis, the report said. The IEA said in 2021 that no new fossil fuel projects could go ahead from 2022 if the world is to tackle global heating and its worsening impacts on billions of people. Several major studies have shown that the vast majority of existing fossil fuel reserves must remain underground to avoid climate breakdown. Many observers argue that getting off fossil fuels, through cheap renewables and efficiency, is the fast and permanent solution to high energy prices.

But the analysis found that 655 of 685 (96%) of exploration and production companies have expansion plans, which have increased by 20% since 2021. 

It also found expansion plans for the export of liquefied gas around the world would more than double under current plans. This would lead to emissions equivalent to the current annual emissions of the African continent. The surge in liquefied gas export plans is centred in North America, with 44% of global liquefaction plants under development located in the US and 11% in Canada. Most of this gas would be produced by fracking. QatarEnergy and Gazprom are also among the companies with the biggest liquefied gas plans.

“Liquefied gas is a false solution,” said Lucie Pinson, at the NGO Reclaim Finance. “The newly planned projects will come too late to solve Europe’s energy crisis. But they will lock us into a high-carbon.”

The Urgewald analysis found companies with the biggest net zero-busting plans are Saudi Aramco, QatarEnergy and Abu Dhabi National Oil Company, followed by Exxon Mobil, TotalEnergies and Chevron. 

“The outcome of our calculations is truly frightening: oil and gas companies’ short-term expansion plans are not in line with the net zero emissions course put forward by the IEA,” says Fiona Hauke at Urgewald. “Keeping these oil and gas resources in the ground is the bare minimum of what is needed to keep 1.5C attainable.”

“The oil and gas companies are betting against our collective future,” said Katrin Ganswindt, at Urgewald.

The Urgewald report said Egypt, host of Cop27, is the “perfect example of the complete disconnect between the action needed and the reality on the ground”. It said 55 companies are exploring for new oil and gas resources across Egypt.

Oil and gas firms planning ‘frightening’ fossil fuels growth, report finds | Climate crisis | The Guardian

Britain needs more immigrant workers

 Lord Simon Wolfson, the chief executive of the clothing and homeware retailer Next, Conservative peer and Brexit supporter, has urged the government to make it easier to allow foreign workers into the UK.

“We have got people queueing up to come to this country to pick crops that are rotting in fields, to work in warehouses that otherwise wouldn’t be operable, and we’re not letting them in,” Lord Wolfson said 

‘Not the Brexit I wanted’: Next boss calls for more foreign workers in UK | Supply chain crisis | The Guardian



Big Pharma – Protecting Profits

More than 1,400 people around the world are still dying each day from Covid-19, and poor nations are still struggling to obtain sufficient vaccine doses and therapeutics. To date, just 23.4% of people in low-income countries have received at least one coronavirus vaccine dose. 

Big Pharma has made no secret of its opposition to waiving patents for coronavirus vaccines. A new investigation details the extent of the powerful industry’s behind-the-scenes lobbying push as it sought to crush an effort to ramp up global production and distribution of the lifesaving shots.  The agreement the World Trade Organization finally approved in June—almost two years and millions of coronavirus deaths later—was so thoroughly gutted that it could no longer be accurately described as a waiver.

Joint reporting by Politico and The Bureau of Investigative Journalism (TBIJ) revealed that pharmaceutical giants threatened several countries, including Belgium and Indonesia, with investment cuts if they decided to support a popular proposal to temporarily lift patent protections that have hindered vaccine production and distribution throughout the ongoing Covid-19 pandemic. The pharmaceutical giants directly pressured and threatened country officials over the patent waiver.

“Big Pharma used its vast lobbying and influencing efforts to try to kill a proposal that threatened the very tenets of the industry,” the outlets report. “Top industry executives enjoyed direct access to senior officials within the E.U., which was opposed to the proposal from the very start and encouraged potentially rogue member states, including Italy and France, to fall into line.”

“And the U.S., after a dramatic late intervention in favor of a waiver for vaccines eight months after the proposal had been tabled, failed to follow through as the Biden administration came under pressure from industry and Congress.”

Soon after Belgium’s development cooperation minister Meryame Kitir appeared on TV to support a lifting of vaccine IP protections in late April 2021, the adviser received a call from Janssen’s public affairs spokesperson.

“According to the adviser, [to the Belgian prime minister] the spokesperson warned them that if Belgium supported a radical proposal made by India and South Africa at the World Trade Organization, then Janssen might rethink its vast billion-dollar research and development investments in Belgium,” 

Between January 2020 and September 2022, 13 pharmaceutical lobby groups and companies held nearly 100 meetings with the most senior European Commission officials. In the U.K., there were more than 360 meetings between January 2020 and March 2022—equivalent to nearly one every two days. Boris Johnson personally attended 11 of them.

Max Lawson, co-chair of the People’s Vaccine Alliance and head of inequality policy at Oxfam, said that “these shocking allegations are a testament to the huge unaccountable power of big business in global politics. Millions died without access to vaccines while pharmaceutical companies gouged extraordinary profits from the pandemic…” He continued,  “Rich countries expressed warm words and pledged donations, but to Germany, the U.K., Switzerland, and the European Commission, it was apparently just a PR exercise. In the end, global solidarity was snuffed out by the wealthy pharmaceutical lobby…”

Outrage as Investigation Shows How Big Pharma ‘Snuffed Out’ Vaccine Patent Waiver (commondreams.org)

Younger Becoming Poorer

 The Institute for Fiscal Studies said wealth had grown rapidly compared with earnings from work since the 2008 financial crisis, driven by a surge in house prices and financial assets – such as stocks and shares – at a time of flatlining progress for average wages. The IFS found wealth levels growing at much faster rates than income meant it was now harder for working families to enter the ranks of the rich in Britain through hard work alone.

Robert Joyce, the deputy director of the IFS, said: “A generation of Britons has ridden a wave of growing asset prices, pushing up the value of their houses and investments. Meanwhile, more than a decade of stagnant earnings has held back younger generations for whom earning their own economic success has become increasingly difficult.” He added,  “The fact that we can no longer be sure that the young will grow up with living standards that match their predecessors is a remarkable social change.”

It said the amount of time it would take to earn enough to move from the middle wealth bracket to the top had increased by almost six years compared with a decade ago. In 2008, it took 10 years’ worth of typical full-time gross earnings to move from the middle to the top wealth bracket. By 2018, this had increased to almost 16 years.

“…it is wealth that is increasingly at the heart of the most pressing economic inequalities today,” the report said.  Average wage growth has stalled over the past decade, with typical pay worth less today than in 2007 after inflation is taken into account.

The economics thinktank said the rapid increases for those who already owned wealth had coincided with a long-term stagnation in earnings. This meant younger adults in particular could “no longer expect to see greatly improving living standards as they age” compared with the faster pay rises and access to cheaper housing enjoyed by their parents’ generation.

 The IFS said only 36% of those born in the 1980s owned their own home by the age of 30, compared with 55% for those born in the 1970s and over 60% of those born in the 1950s and 1960s.  Inherited wealth was becoming more important for the lifetime economic resources of younger generations.

Rising asset wealth and falling real wages ‘drive inequality in Britain’ | Economics | The Guardian

World Cup Hell

 



Less than three weeks to go before the Qatar World Cup kicks off. Krishna Timislina worked for several years at construction sites for the stadiums the conditions were “hell on earth”. Sometimes 18 hour working days in searing heat and powered by energy drinks), water of dubious quality, prefab housing without space or privacy, and people dying from accidents or exhaustion.

 He told French journalists Sébastian Castelier and Quentin Muller for their book “Les Esclaves de l’Homme Pétrole” (“The Oil Man’s Slaves”) that with “precarious living conditions, terrible water quality and interminable shifts, we know our health is being damaged – but do we have a choice?” He explained, “So much of Qatar is being built thanks to our work – stadiums, shopping malls, bridges and roads are being constructed – but we’re not invited to share in the dream.” 

 Qatar has used a massive influx of foreign workers to build the infrastructure for the footballing extravaganza – with migrants building roads, a new airport, a railway network and seven new stadiums. However, the human cost has been dreadful. 

In a report published in August 2022, Amnesty International said that more than 15,021 foreigners of all ages and occupations had died in Qatar between 2010 and 2019. A February 2021 investigation found that at least 6,751 migrant workers died in Qatar from 2010 to 2020. But Castelier noted the real number is likely much higher. “These figures mainly come from Asian embassies in Qatar; we don’t have the statistics for African workers there.”  That figure also does not take into account workers who die after returning home. They point out that many such untimely deaths are due to kidney problems following the consumption of unsafe water. An Amnesty International investigation found that at least 6,751 migrant workers died in Qatar from 2010 to 2020 from drinking homemade alcohol and energy drinks as they struggle to keep up with the frantic work pace.

Qatar’s climate has a lot to do with the high mortality rate. “It’s very hot in the summer,” Castelier said. “It’s just hell working in the construction industry. Qatar has banned working outdoors in the open from 10:30am to 3pm, but many violations have been reported.”

Lack of training can be another cause of death. “They put people who haven’t been trained on huge machines or on scaffolding, and they often have no idea about safety measures – so there are plenty of accidents,” Castelier said. Qatar knows all this makes for bad PR: “It’s perfectly aware that the stories about migrants workers are a problem; they’re constantly trying to put forward a narrative that they’re a modernising country.”

Qatar hosts nearly 400,000 migrant workers, often in conditions of modern-day slavery.

“It’s like a disposable workforce,” Castelier said. “That’s how migration to the Gulf states works. It’s impossible for an immigrant to obtain local citizenship. So when they’re no longer working, they have to leave.” Migrants arriving in Gulf states soon fall prey to an exploitative system, with “kafala” at the heart of it. In a widely used system in the Gulf, a sponsor (or “kafeel”) is assigned to each migrant, often his or her employer. The system puts migrants at the mercy of their employers, who often confiscate their passports upon arrival.

The kafala system “gives the employer a lot of power over the employee”, Castelier said. “Everything is OK if the employer respects the rules. But if not, the employee’s life can become a living hell.”

In a public relations attempt to improve its image, Qatar officially abolished the kafala system in 2016. Yet in reality, “many aspects of it are still in force”, Castelier said. “Most notably, an employer can say that a migrant working for them is a fugitive. So if a domestic worker, for example, wants to denounce abuses by their employer, the latter can easily say that they have absconded – and instead of looking into the worker’s complaints, the police will just return them to their employer.”

‘Just hell’: New book shines light on migrant deaths ahead of Qatar World Cup (france24.com)

Socialist Sonnet No. 85

COP27

 

Climate in crisis, temperatures soaring,

Hurricanes vying with droughts to be worse

And humanity’s primary curse,

As sea levels rise. It’s worth restoring

Equilibrium surely? And yet,

Perhaps the problem is just too intense:

The only response, another conference

For politicians to attend by jet.

Banquets are arranged, discussions begun,

Though radical measures are rejected

If it seems profits might be affected,

Even though all say something must be done.

A strong resolution, they’re all for it,

Until they fly home and then ignore it.

 

D. A.

Pessimistic Climate Prognosis for the USA

 



A new draft US federal report from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), the National Science Foundation, and NASA  notes that the country, the largest emitter of carbon in history, is warming faster than the Earth as a whole, with the continental U.S. 1.3°C (2.5°F) warmer than it was in the 1970s. The planet has warmed 1.1°C or 2°F above preindustrial temperatures.

Millions of people in the U.S. have already had firsthand experience with the impacts of the climate crisis, says the report. More than 3,000 homes and other structures were destroyed by wildfires in California in 2021, and a heatwave across the Pacific Northwest last year killed 229 people. As climate scientists have consistently warned, hurricanes are growing more severe.  According to the report. “Many of the harmful impacts that people across the country are already experiencing will worsen as warming increases, and new risks will emerge.”

The report warns that “more severe wildfires in California, sea level rise in Florida, and more frequent flooding in Texas are expected to displace millions of people” in the United States.

Four decades ago, disasters costing $1 billion or more took place roughly once every four months, but 20 such events were recorded in 2021, averaging about one every three weeks. 

“Compound events—combinations of weather or climate events affecting one location back-to-back or multiple locations at the same time—are already occurring in every region of the country and are projected to become more frequent as the world continues to warm,” the draft report reads. “These events have cascading effects through supply chains, food networks, and other interdependent systems that typically cause greater harm than isolated events.”

Some climate harms facing Americans that have been covered less frequently than extreme weather, including threats to drinking water supplies as rising sea levels send saltwater into aquifers and flooding pollutes wells and other sources. Other public health risks include rising tick populations and the spread of Lyme disease amid warmer weather, increased transmission of mosquito-borne illnesses, and the inhalation of toxic wildfire smoke in communities across the West.

“Faster, deeper cuts” to fossil fuel emissions that are needed to see a 6% annual reduction, which the report says is necessary to reach net-zero emissions by 2050.

Report Demands ‘Rapid Transition’ to Renewables as Climate Calamities Spread Across US (commondreams.org)

Greenwashing at the COP

 “A growing number of governments and nonstate actors are pledging to be carbon-free—and obviously that’s good news,” Guterres said while introducing a report, entitled Integrity Matters: Net-Zero Commitments by Businesses, Financial Institutions, Cities, and Regions, “The problem is that the criteria and benchmarks for these net-zero commitments have varying levels of rigor and loopholes wide enough to drive a diesel truck through.”

“We must have zero tolerance for net-zero greenwashing,” he continued. “Today’s expert group report is a how-to guide to ensure credible, accountable net-zero pledges. Let’s tell it like it is. Using bogus ‘net-zero’ pledges to cover up massive fossil fuel expansion is reprehensible. It is rank deception. This toxic cover-up could push our world over the climate cliff. The sham must end. “

“We urgently need every business, investor, city, state, and region to walk the talk on their net-zero promises,” Guterres added. “We cannot afford slow movers, fake movers, or any form of greenwashing.”

“This analysis only scratches the surface of how deeply conflicted these ‘net-zero’ initiatives are,” Sara Shaw, climate justice and energy international program coordinator for Friends of the Earth International, said in a statement. “It paints a picture of how this isn’t just about polluters trying to build ‘green credibility,’ but of how they position themselves to shape and obstruct policy progress.”

Climate Defenders Urge ‘Zero Tolerance for Net-Zero Greenwashing’ as UN Publishes New Report (commondreams.org)